Paper alert – Molybdenum isotopes in basalts, and potential constraints on the redox state of subducted slabs

It's fresh off the press, Qasid Ahmad and co-authors (including yours truly) just published a short paper at GPL (here) providing some constraints on the redox state of subducted slabs, using molybdenum isotopes. And yes, articles in Geochemical Perspective Letters are fully open-access, thanks to the EAG support. 


Qasid's paper is titled "Molybdenum isotopes in plume-influenced MORBs reveal recycling of ancient anoxic sediments"



Using this new work to re-activate this page, but note that i've posted a short thread on twitter, check it out below.

The studied objects here are basalts dredged up on the South-Atlantic mid-ocean ridge. These basalts record well-known interactions between the sub-oceanic mantle and plume-derived components, delivered to the ridge by both the Shona and the Discovery hotspots.



The new finding in this work is the observation of correlations between Mo stable isotopes and radiogenic isotope tracers such as Nd and Sr isotopes.



This is important, because this shows that Mo isotopes behave as a source tracer, at least in these basalts. these trends do not seem universal, as literature data (smaller symbols) show a distinct behavior than our new measurements. Anyways, we were able to conclude that something unique, with an enriched geochemical composition, contributes to the source of these basalts. Mixing between the mantle and that enriched component generate the observed correlations.

For those who would want to learn more, these trends were already observed in 2013 and in 2020 for sulfur and selenium isotopes in the very same samples. Nice to see it further confirmed with molybdenum! 

Taken together, those multiple trends tell us that whatever is enriched in these sources must be enriched in sulfur, selenium, but also in molybdenum. We conclude that ~1-2% Proterozoic sediment could easily explain the data. Now interestingly, Qasid performed a least square error analysis on the data. He found that the molybdenum isotope composition of the recycled sediment is likely anywhere in the 'bluest' domain in the figure below (left and right, for a data fit for Sr and Nd isotope respectively). Definitely not dealing with a sediment of Phanerozoic age, right? 



Now and that's the coolest part of the paper: the recycled sediment does not appear to be fractionated compared to the un-subducted protoliths. The data can easily be satisfied with sediments observed at the surface of the Earth (i.e. that never were obliterated by subduction). It's as if the recycled sediments underwent no Mo isotope fractionation. 

That's critical: only oxic conditions in slabs can lead to Mo isotope fractionations, according to the well-referenced work of Qasid. This means that whatever is subducted must have been a rather reducing rock, so molybdenum isotopes undergo no measurable fractionation. What this means for Earth's surface evolution? well, subduction must have evolved in time. Ahmad et al., suggest the evolution was abrupt, at the Proterozoic-Phanerozoic transition, reflecting the abrupt evolution in ocean chemistry. The prediction is that Mo isotope fractionation would occur during subduction only in the Phanerozoic and onward...



Neat!


So, we ask, can we really use modern subduction to infer redox-sensitive element fluxes in subduction zones, back in time?

Molybdenum isotopes in plume-influenced MORBs reveal recycling of ancient anoxic sediments (2022), by Ahmad et al., 





Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Jabrane Labidi - The black lives matter movement - challenging anti-black racism in academia

Image
BLACK LIVES MATTER -  challenging the status quo in academia  In the wake of the murder of George Floyd and Breonna Taylor, academics must challenge their bias against our black peers. In this excellent, gut-wrenching piece,  here (absolute read), Charles D. Brown II shows that less than 2% of earth science bachelor's degrees in the US went to black students in 2017, the lowest rates among all STEM fields. The statistics do not exist in Europe due to a regressive legislation, but it would be reasonable to assume the numbers are comparable, at best, or probably even less favorable to black folxs in academia.  The geochemical society, through the leadership of Roberta Rudnick, decided to take a stand, which i commend. For the online goldschmidt of 2020, a town hall about racism was organized, and i had the privilege to say a few words about our issues in academia, and specifically in our field. I was joined by three brilliant early career scientists: Emily Cooperdock (USC), James Do
Read more

Jabrane Labidi - DEI effort at the EAG

Image
I enthusiastically joined the Diversity, Equality, and Inclusion sub-group at the European Association of Geochemistry. Our goal will be to  "promote DEI initiatives that cultivate welcoming, kind, inspiring, and actively anti-discriminatory scientific cultures as well as safe, healthy, and supportive working environments. As such, the EAG DEI initiative shall serve as a model for STEM in optimizing participation of historically excluded and underrepresented peoples across all sectors, levels of employ, and positions of community leadership." This is an initiative to tackle racism and other biases in our academic circles. We hope to not only raise awareness on how gated geochemistry appears to be for underrepresented folks, but also to produce content describing key aspects of our problem at hand. We intend on discussing the intricate aspects of social reproduction within academia on a worldwide scale, but also with a special target on European institutions. We will host a n
Read more

Nitrogen isotopologues reveal the origin of nitrogen in our planetary interior - Jabrane Labidi

Hi All,  We've published our work in the journal Nature. We show that we can eliminate the confounding effect of air contamination in volcanic and hydrothermal gases, for the specific case of nitrogen. By substracting air contamination, we derive the di-nitrogen (N 2 ) molecular weight in various mantle sources.  A new finding here is that various mantle sources, with variable 15N/14N ratios, have a near-constant N2/3He ratio. Because 3He is in the deep Earth is not recycled, the constant N2/3He ratios argue against nitrogen addition via subduction in various mantle sources.  We built a 2-box model to show how over 4.5 Ga, the mantle and air may have exchanged considerably less nitrogen than previously suggested. In other words, the possibility that mantle nitrogen is primordial can no longer be excluced. In this theory, nitrogen would have been inherited from the time the Earth was being built via planetary accretion.  proud of this work! Here is a link to vi
Read more